ConvictedSalt Lake City, UT

Elizabeth Smart Kidnapping

#kidnapping#utah#child-victim#found-alive#religious-extremism
Apr 9, 2026

14-year-old Elizabeth Smart was abducted at knifepoint from her bedroom in Salt Lake City on June 5, 2002, by Brian David Mitchell, a self-proclaimed street prophet. Mitchell and his wife Wanda Barzee held Smart captive for nine months, often moving through Utah and California. Smart was found alive on March 12, 2003 in Sandy, Utah, after a public sighting. Mitchell was convicted in 2010 and sentenced to life in prison.

Case overview

LocationSalt Lake City, UT
IncidentJune 5, 2002
ResolvedMarch 12, 2003
StatusConvicted
Case typekidnapping
VictimElizabeth Smart

On June 5, 2002, 14-year-old Elizabeth Smart was taken at knifepoint from her bedroom in her family's home in the Federal Heights neighborhood of Salt Lake City, Utah. Her younger sister Mary Katherine, age nine, witnessed the abduction from the same bedroom but remained still out of fear. Elizabeth Smart was held captive for nine months, subjected to sexual assault and psychological manipulation, before being found alive and returned to her family. CNN

The kidnapping prompted a massive search effort, one of the most extensive in Utah history, and significant media coverage. Elizabeth was the daughter of Ed Smart, a prominent real estate broker, and Lois Smart. She was taken by Brian David Mitchell, a self-styled street preacher who had done handyman work for the Smart family a year earlier.

Mitchell, who called himself "Emmanuel," believed he was carrying out God's command to take polygamous "wives." He and his wife Wanda Barzee held Elizabeth in a makeshift campsite in the foothills above Salt Lake City, then moved her to San Diego and Las Vegas. Throughout her captivity, Elizabeth was often in public but disguised with robes and a veil.

In October 2002, Mary Katherine recalled that the man who had taken Elizabeth was the same handyman "Emmanuel" who had worked for the family. This identification narrowed the investigation. America's Most Wanted featured the story, and in March 2003, viewers in the San Diego area spotted Elizabeth walking near Sandy, Utah with Mitchell and Barzee and called police. The Guardian

Elizabeth Smart was found alive on March 12, 2003, after nine months of captivity. She was 15 years old. Her rescue inspired national celebration and renewed discussions about child safety, abduction prevention, and how communities search for missing children. NPR

Mitchell and Barzee were immediately arrested when Elizabeth was found. Both were charged with federal kidnapping and other crimes. The prosecution was complicated by Mitchell's extensive bizarre behavior and both his and his defense team's claims of incompetency.

Barzee eventually pleaded guilty in 2010 and was sentenced to more than 15 years in federal and state prison. She was released in September 2018.

Mitchell's trial was delayed for years due to competency hearings and appeals. He was found competent to stand trial in 2010. His trial finally began in November 2010. Elizabeth Smart testified at the trial, facing her captor and providing detailed testimony about the abuse she endured. Washington Post

On December 10, 2010, a federal jury convicted Mitchell of all charges, including kidnapping a minor and taking a minor across state lines for sexual purposes. BBC

On May 25, 2011, U.S. District Judge Dale Kimball sentenced Brian Mitchell to two life sentences — one for each federal charge. AP News

Elizabeth Smart became a prominent advocate for victims of kidnapping and sexual violence. She married Matthew Gilmour in 2012, has three children, and co-founded the Elizabeth Smart Foundation, which provides education on personal safety to children.

2011

May 25, 2011

Mitchell Sentenced to Life in Prison

Federal Judge Dale Kimball sentences Brian David Mitchell to two concurrent life sentences, plus 15 additional years. Wanda Barzee, who pleaded guilty in 2009, had already been sentenced to 15 years.

Source →
2010

December 10, 2010

Mitchell Convicted of All Federal Charges

Following multiple competency delays, Brian David Mitchell is convicted of kidnapping and transportation for sexual activity in federal court. Elizabeth Smart testified in detail during the trial.

Source →
2003

March 12, 2003

Elizabeth Smart Found Alive in Sandy, Utah

A passing couple recognizes Mitchell and Barzee — who had appeared on America's Most Wanted — walking with a disguised young woman along a Sandy, Utah street. Police are called and Elizabeth Smart is identified and freed, nine months after her abduction.

Source →
2002

October 1, 2002

Mary Katherine Identifies "Emmanuel"

Elizabeth's sister Mary Katherine tells her parents she recognizes the kidnapper's voice as that of "Emmanuel," a street preacher who had briefly worked at their home. The detail renews focus on Mitchell as a suspect, though he is not immediately located.

Source →

June 5, 2002

Elizabeth Smart Kidnapped from Her Bedroom

Brian David Mitchell enters the Smart home in Salt Lake City and abducts 14-year-old Elizabeth Smart at knifepoint. Her sister Mary Katherine, 9, witnesses the abduction but remains silent out of fear. The family discovers Elizabeth missing several hours later.

Source →
Loading…

Relationship data not yet mapped — nodes positioned by force simulation.

Victim
Suspect / Convicted
Unknown Subject
Witness
Investigator
Attorney
TestimonialKey

Mary Katherine Smart's Eyewitness Account

Elizabeth's 9-year-old sister Mary Katherine witnessed the abduction but kept silent for months out of fear. Her eventual identification of the kidnapper as "Emmanuel" — a man who had briefly worked as a handyman at the family home — was the investigative breakthrough that pointed police to Mitchell.

en.wikipedia.org
TestimonialKey

Elizabeth Smart's Testimony

Elizabeth Smart testified over two days at Mitchell's 2010 trial, providing a detailed first-person account of her nine-month captivity, the daily conditions, and the repeated sexual abuse she endured. Her composure and clarity during testimony was widely praised and was the prosecution's most powerful evidence.

en.wikipedia.org
DocumentaryKey

Public Sighting — America's Most Wanted Recognition

Mitchell and Barzee had appeared on America's Most Wanted on February 26, 2003. Within two weeks, a couple in Sandy, Utah, recognized them walking with Smart. Their call to police led directly to Elizabeth's rescue. The case is frequently cited as demonstrating the effectiveness of public awareness campaigns in missing persons cases.

Salt Lake City Police Department Booking Photo, Mar 12, 2003 (via CBS News)
DocumentarySupporting

Mitchell's "Book of Immanuel David Isaiah" — Religious Journal

Mitchell had written a religious manifesto called the "Book of Immanuel David Isaiah" justifying his polygamous ideology and claiming divine authority. The document helped establish the ideological framework he imposed on Smart and was central to understanding his motive and methods.

en.wikipedia.org
DocumentarySupporting

Elizabeth Smart — Advocate and Author

Following her rescue, Elizabeth Smart became a prominent advocate for child safety and victims' rights. She has authored two books about her experience and founded the Elizabeth Smart Foundation. This photo, taken after her recovery, shows her as an adult in her advocacy role.

en.wikipedia.org